28 Jul, 2020

Other Men’s Flowers

I have gathered a posie of other men’s flowers

and nothing but the thread that

binds them is my own.

MONTAIGNE

I have held this book, Other Men’s Flowers, close to me for 50 years.  In different places and at different times it has been an interest, a companion, a comfort, an inspiration, and a saviour.  It was the first volume that came to mind when I let the memory wander through the decades: Cambridge, Sudan, Libya, Saudi Arabia, global travel, UK executive life, career and performance counselling, volunteering and more.  I am in love with the book.

You might know it already.  In 1941, in the darkest days of the Second World War, in the few months between staving off the German assault on the Middle East and then turning to meet the challenge of Japan, Field-Marshal Earl Wavell listed his favourite poems for a ‘family conversation’, a small pleasantry to take their minds off those threatening times.  Family members reminded him of others that he knew. Two years later, when he was Viceroy of India, the anthology was published.  An instant success.

In my last few weeks at Cambridge, knowing that the next few years would see me somewhat isolated in Africa, I bought the book.  Why?  No idea, and the memory doesn’t help.  What is certain is that in 1969 I had no special interest in poetry; I knew little; and I can’t remember wanting to know more.  Also, I don’t remember anyone suggesting it.

Perhaps it was the start of that sense of ‘future nostalgia’, the awareness that a golden period of life was coming to an end, that what was to come would be very alien and very different, and that perhaps something that could remind me of the western world, and particularly of the British world (all I knew at the time) would be valuable.  It turned out to be invaluable.

My edition of Other Men’s Flowers runs to over 400 pages.  Astonishingly, Lord Wavell states that he knew and could recite every single poem.  He came from that generation whose schooling taught and encouraged a love of literature and poetry.  He also had a very good memory, as he states in his Preface.  And he started early: as a small boy he learned Macauley’s ‘Horatius’ and then: “Admiring aunts used to give me threepence for reciting it from beginning to end.  A wiser uncle gave me sixpence for a promise to do nothing of the kind”.

So Wavell grew to be a romantic warrior, ruler of India, humorously pulling rank in the depths of war: “My Aides-de-Camp have to listen politely when I quote verse to them – that is a privilege of a Commander-in-Chief”.  What did he quote?  He was a man of his time though often preferring earlier works: the favourites were Browning, Kipling, Chesterton, Masefield, Keats, Shelley, Macaulay, Scott, but others feature also, including verses by persons unknown.

In the book the poems are arranged in themes: Music, Mystery and Magic ; Good Fighting ; Love And All That ; The Call Of The Wild ; Conversation Pieces ; The Lighter Side ; Hymns of Hate ; Ragbag ; Last Post.  Now think about this: what part of our lives, our experiences, our triumphs and disasters, would not fit under those headings?  Most of mine have, and still do.   Over the years I’ve used the book often, with little attempt to memorise any of it but knowing where to look for favourites and answers.  A few short ones have stayed in the memory however, and the rhythm of many others.

In the Sudan I shared some of the simpler ones with my local teacher colleagues and the students. The students were learning English language and literature but no poetry, so for them it was an added dimension to the language and culture.

In Libya, in the Sahara, the oilmen wouldn’t have been interested so Other Men’s Flowers was my private comfort.  In Saudi Arabia there were times when stress levels were high and I needed to remind myself of the monumental pressures borne by others such as Wavell, and of the humanity that still shone through them.

These last 30 years in the UK, coping or not coping with national and international responsibilities, it’s been a pleasure and a release to delve into the anthology for words of support and strength and for echoes of fellow-travellers through the ups and downs of life.  Right now, with my condition, I find solace.

Wavell’s anecdotes add much to the enjoyment.  He sets contexts, much as I am doing now.  He tells short stories.  He adds tiny poems from friends.  If anyone reads the book for the first time do please read the Prefaces, and in the right order: Wavell’s preface to the first edition, then his preface to the revised edition, and then his son’s introduction to the memorial edition.

So where are we now, we proud, sophisticated westerners, in these so-called progressive, industrially successful, commercially and scientifically advanced times, having achieved so much?  A reminder from Other Men’s Flowers:

CALIPH: Ah, if there shall ever arise a nation whose people have forgotten poetry or whose poets have forgotten the people, though they send their ships around Taprobane and their armies across the hills of Hindustan, though their city be greater than Babylon of old, and though they mine a league into earth or mount to the stars on wings – what of them?

HASSAN: They will be a dark patch upon the world.

3 Comments

  1. Dave, you gave us this wonderful anthology twenty three years ago, after a holiday in Cornwall. You said then that you had three previous copies! You dedicated this one to all the family, including my father. He loved, and could also recite by heart, many of these poems. As could my granny! This is a much enjoyed, and well worn copy now. There are markings still in place from when Malc used to select things to read to pupils and for them to read too. So a treasure of a book and great to hear the ways its been part of your life for so long.

    Reply
  2. David, you gave us a copy of this in 1985 — Dhahran, Saudi Arabia. When I read your post I went immediately to the shelf to take it down and– it fell open to Francis Thompson’s Arab Love-Song. Camels and black tents of the tribe. The book reminisces as well. Yes, music, mystery and magic and desert nights and days with old friends. Thank you again — you said then that you had carried it for fifteen years, and I have traveled with it for the past thirty-five. And now, I shall sit down to read awhile.

    Reply
  3. This was the only book my father ever gave me, back in the late 60s, and it sits on my book shelf to this day. He once told me it was of great solace to him following his POW experiences on the River Kwai. Some wonderful poems and a brilliant anthology

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Other posts

Tough Discipline, again ….

Tough Discipline, again ….

Following the last blog post, other examples are: The same 1972 university course but this time teaching in Spain.  We TEFL (Teaching English as a Foreign Language) trainees were sent to Barcelona...

read more
Tough Discipline …

Tough Discipline …

Well, the memory bank was triggered yesterday by a report on the unruly behaviour of some students, partly or wholly as a result of boredom during the lockdown.  Unusual punishments from my dodgy...

read more
Findings …

Findings …

No change on the health front.  Still much the same, so let’s move on.  Something along the lines of “That reminds me of when ….” The local residents’ association here, which I used to run, covers...

read more