28 Apr, 2021

APPG. Worth it?

Continuing one of the items from the last blog post, at 2pm yesterday afternoon I received an email from Dignity in Dying.  It said that they had just received permission from Matt Hancock’s office to live-stream the online All Party Parliamentary Group discussion on ‘Choice at the End of Life’, scheduled for 5pm, three hours later.  Not much notice, but there was little else to do here so I watched it.

It lasted just under an hour.  Five people on the screen.  Andrew Mitchell, Conservative MP, leading it.  Matt Hancock, Secretary of State for Health, responding to questions.  A Baroness who said nothing.  An MP who seems to run the Group but wasn’t involved in the discussion.  And a member of the public who described the tragic end of her father’s life.  Andrew Mitchell asked his own questions and other questions supplied by MPs who presumably were watching it, as was I.

What can I say?  Credit to Dignity in Dying for managing to get the thing discussed at all.  A passable performance by Andrew Mitchell.  A dreadful performance by Matt Hancock.

I make no political point here. In these 206 blog posts I’ve steered clear of political comment.  Also, I don’t like saying negative things about individuals in public, and I don’t think I have.  The point I would make though, is that this is a vitally important subject.  In more than one sense it’s a matter of life and death.  Given that it’s sensitive, one might expect a Minister to be cautious and project a non-committal approach, but the meanderings and inconsequential platitudes of our Mr Hancock were truly dismal.  Whether the meeting has moved anything forward I doubt.  We’ll see.

It lasted almost an hour,  For brave souls, the full talk is here.  The most impactful part was Barbara’s account of her father’s death.  If you’re interested, it’s here.

2 Comments

  1. I just watched the clip of Barbara – very moving and powerful. Completely agree about Matt Hancock based on his ‘responses’ following that section.

    In case any tiny consolation, I thought I’d share an email back from my MP, Mel Stride: that he was sorry to read about your situation, and hopes that you are doing as well as can be; apologising that he couldn’t make the APPG meeting; and stating “I do have a settled view that a competent adult who is terminally ill should be provided at his or her request with specified assistance to end his or her own life subject to appropriate safeguards.”

    Well done again, you, for your part in promoting Dignity In Dying, and for finding the physical and emotional energy to share all this 💛

    Reply
  2. I’ve just watched it and agree, completely with you and Chris about Matt Hancock. Every question seemed to be fielded with ‘ a need for debate’ The debate needs to happen and then come up with the right answers! The moving story of Barbara’s father must strike a chord with many. My father was totally of the view that one should have the right to die wth dignity and, importantly, when still able to make that choice. And I’m sure that very many of us feel the same

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Other posts

Tough Discipline, again ….

Tough Discipline, again ….

Following the last blog post, other examples are: The same 1972 university course but this time teaching in Spain.  We TEFL (Teaching English as a Foreign Language) trainees were sent to Barcelona...

read more
Tough Discipline …

Tough Discipline …

Well, the memory bank was triggered yesterday by a report on the unruly behaviour of some students, partly or wholly as a result of boredom during the lockdown.  Unusual punishments from my dodgy...

read more
Findings …

Findings …

No change on the health front.  Still much the same, so let’s move on.  Something along the lines of “That reminds me of when ….” The local residents’ association here, which I used to run, covers...

read more